Quote:
Quote:
SPOT use geosynchronous satelites. There's no "waiting" for coverage, there is no "low on the horizon" stuff either. You are either in the coverage area or you aren't.


I'll bet you the cost of a real PLB that SPOT does NOT use geosynchronous satellites.

Are we agreed that SPOT uses the Globalstar satellite network for service? If we are, then here it is right from Globalstar's website

Quote:
(Excerpt from site)

The Globalstar constellation consists of 40 Low Earth Orbiting (LEO) satellites, with an additional four satellites in orbit as spares.


SPOT does show you Globalstar's coverage map, but as any cell phone user can tell you, coverage maps and reality are two different things. What the map means is that under ideal conditions, this is the coverage area you can expect. Conditions are seldom ideal.

Now that this is settled, let's talk about the 911 feature again. If you don't buy the extra tracking feature or have it turned off, I stand by my previous assessment of SPOTs utility. Here's what the SPOT website has to say about it:

Quote:
Even if SPOT cannot acquire its location from the GPS network it will still attempt to send a distress signal – without exact location – to the Emergency Response Center, which will still notify your contacts of the signal and continue to monitor the network for further messages.


The part in bold assumes that a message actually gets through, which from my and most other users' experience isn't going to happen if the GPS is unable to obtain a fix. Notice that no mention is made of trying to determine your position from previous fixes? I suppose if your contacts know you have tracking they'll look on the website for your last position, but it doesn't look like SPOT automatically does this.

As I said before - if SPOT works for you, great! But stop spreading misinformation about the system just because you bought one.


I sit corrected about the satelites - you are correct.

You are wrong about HELP and 911 - SPOT will transmit the message even though it can't get a GPS fix. Receiving a GPS signal and transmitting to Globalstar are two different activities.

And you are still totally wrong about the usage model. You keep thinking like a "use only in an emergency" EPLB. If that were SPOTs goal, they would crank the transmit power way up until it burned the canopy away for a clear view of the sky <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

But their usage model is lots of communication. So if you turn SPOT off until an emergency - you screwed up.

I'm a happy SPOT user, one of many. You should stop spreading misinformation just because you don't want to buy one and don't understand how it is used.


Edited by dla (08/21/08 06:43 PM)