So I think I have narrowed it down, but any thoughts would be appreciated.

1. One Earth Goondie 2 - I really like the stable construction/pole design, thick floor (no footprint necessary), and ability to get the mesh with thicker fly meaning more suitable for year round and this trip's possible snow.

2. Marmot Tungsten 2 - at about half the price, this is tempting; probably not quite as solid, but has rave reviews everywhere I look and allows more money for other gear needed. It's a bit heavier plus would need a footprint and is a bit bulkier, though.

Any thoughts on these two tents?