I've used Vasque and Merrell, and found both to be good. However, you shouldn't rely on what any of us like. Shoes are, as you no doubt know, something that you need to try on and find what works and fits best for you, not us. The best bet: go to a store that knows how to fit shoes, and try on whatever they've got. You don't say whether your hiking is dayhiking or overnighting. If you'll be carrying a full load of gear, then take a packed pack with you and try it on with the finalists - an extra 20, 30, or 40 pounds can affect the fit of your shoes.

If you don't have a nearby store, and are forced to use online sources, then try to choose one with a good return policy: order several pairs, and send back the "losers."