Originally Posted By SinanDira
So the bottom line is that using leather boots is a terribly impractical idea for water crossings, and having them as my primary pair will require an alternative solution for crossing water.
Correct (if you want to care for your feet better). Yes, soldiers wear them through water but dry feet isn't top priority for them though they are also most likely to have trench foot. Those in wetter climes would often wear jungle boots that have drain holes at least. Dr. Martens are known for comfort but they aren't meant for water either. Very popular with factory workers.

For just hiking, I'd go with the lightest you can get (sandals you mentioned). Not sure whether those would be suitable for your other "outdoor activities" though.

It may be that you get Dr. Martens AND sandals. Not ideal, but could be what will work best for your situation.