What most of us are saying is that a GPS or any other electronic device can fail. Batteries die, the innards get wet. That's why learning to read a map and use a compass are extremely important.

Just having the gear with you does nothing; it's the same as taking a big first aid kit when you don't have any first aid training. In both cases, it's vitally important to learn how to use it!

It's interesting that the Seattle Mountaineers, who originated the "Ten" Essentials, still include map and compass and say nothing about a GPS.

The whole idea is not how to get "unlost," it's how not to get lost in the first place!

I'm not saying that a GPS isn't useful, but it doesn't replace basic skills!