Good point Glenn... many smaller manufacturers seem to size tents such that you can actually fit the number of people advertised in them. Most of the larger manufacturers use a consistent sizing where you have have to subtract one from the advertised number to determine how many people you would want to stick in there.

Case in point it looks like the Golite Eden 2 has 39 sq ft of floor space with 12 sq. ft in the vestibule. That is considerably larger than the Fly Creek 2 and matches almost exactly with the Fly Creek 3 (39/12.5 sq ft). Lay out is important and I couldn't quickly locate the layout of the Eden 2 but it looks like a rectangle. The BA is sized wider at the top and narrower at the bottom. Either way, it looks like the BA Fly Creek 3 is a better comparison tent at 3 lbs 3 oz (still saving you almost 2 lbs).