Couple questions before I weigh in...

1) What time of year do you intend to use the tent in?

Reason I ask is that bug netting becomes a lot less important Oct-Apr than in May-Sept; and this influences your design preferences.

2) Who are you going to use the tent with (#people total) and do you intend to bring gear (pack, etc) in with you or leave it outside. This effects how big the tent needs to be. A four person tent can feel really empty with one person in it, and it's a pain getting your pack out of the freezing rain in the winter - better to have it inside.

I've used and liked Coleman and Eureka tents, and am starting to like my TarpTent. Many of the tents should really go on sale here in the fall/early winter...