I have used both and two years ago met a hammock backpacker. I have never looked back. It is the most comfortable convenient shelter, as long as there are trees! You can sit up in it with feet on the ground, cook under the tarp, and it is by far the most comfortable night sleep I have ever experienced. There are several brands to choose from and I would test it out at home. There are also some hanging tricks and conversions to make to make set up and adjustments much easier. I would suggest looking into one if you are choosing a shelter.