What MNS said.

Also, IMO any situation dangerous enough to require crampons like that also requires an ice axe as a safety tool and the third part of the triad......the training and experience necessary to use them.

You mentioned hiking, not mountaineering. Your two choices may be overkill.

But then again, you were not specific about the type of terrain/surface/angles you expect to encounter. If you just want to hike on icy trails with no high angle travel I suggest Kahtoola crampons or even their Microspikes .

The downside of the Kahtoolas is that they lack anti-balling plates which can be very handy in some conditions.

I think you should do some research on what you're likely to encounter and then choose a crampon based on your needs. Everything is a compromise.