I am looking to replace my old liners. I have been looking at the mountain hardware butter, the sierra designs cocona, and Under Armour liner gloves. I have long fingers and have tried on the smartwool and the MH in size large and the fingers are a bit short still.

I will be using them with cabelas expedition weight gloves so that i can take the large gloves off to do stuff and still have something on, I walk to school and around town all winter in temps between 20 and -20 F and it is blizzarding 20 to 30% of the time.

what is your experence with the above mentioned brands?
also, i am planning on buying from amazon because i have rewards points from my CC to use for this purchase.