REI dividends arrive soon, so naturally I've started drooling. I'm attracted to the Big Agnes Emerald Mountain SL1 - same dimensions as the Seedhouse SL1 I have and like, but with a side opening that seems more convenient and (I think, from the picture) a high-end vent.
I contacted Big Agnes, and found out that the door is hinged along the bottom. I vaguely remember sharing a tent with a buddy back in the late 80's; it had a bottom-hinged door too. I also remember that door being a PITA: it was always, literally, underfoot. Of course, I only used it for one trip, so I never really developed the habit of rolling it open to tuck along the edge, where I wouldn't step on it every time I got in and out.
What's your experience with bottom-hinged doors? Are they an everlasting nuisance, or is it fairly easy to develop a nearly unconscious habit of dropping them open in such a way that you don't walk on them?
As you point, there are some antique tents that had drop down doors. My Early Winters, which I still use, and Biblers from the '70s are a few that I know of.
As Phat says it is an ongoing nuisance.
I can't imagine why a designer in his right mind would perpetuate this old idea.
When I made the Ray-Way style net-tent, I decided I wanted a zipper door. I discovered that if the tent is more or less "A"-shaped, you don't have many choices. The "D"-shaped door on some tents makes sense, but you need either fairly vertical sides, a large "face" to work with, or a longer zipper. You can use a vertical zipper in the middle, with horizontal zippers at the bottom, but it requires three zippers. I finally decided, grudgingly, to go with the bottom-hinging door. It's a little inconvenient, but not really a big deal.
A-shaped is not a problem...One zipper parallel to one side, turning along the bottom, very little of the door actually "hangs". With velcro or shockcord attachment everything's OK.
Sorry to go against the grain here, but I use tents with that design (BD Firstlight, BD One Shot)and it really doesn't bother me. I simply roll up the door on the inside and it's out of the way. On bigger doors it is also possible to crawl in without fully unzipping and letting it fall to the ground.
With two zippers I can have the door partially open from the top down for any degree of ventilation I need. I don't need ties to hold the door open.
Every design is a compromise but this works for me.
_________________________ If you only travel on sunny days you will never reach your destination.*
* May not apply at certain latitudes in Canada and elsewhere.
I had I think a first-generation SD omega with the bottom-hinged door.. absolutely hated it. Returned it for the next generation that fixed that "problem."
I like the new BA Copper Spur.. but not with that door....
Our long-time Sponsor, BackcountryGear.com - The leading source for ultralite/lightweight outdoor gear:
Affiliate Disclaimer: This forum is an affiliate of BackcountryGear.com, Amazon.com, R.E.I. and others. The product links herein are linked to their sites. If you follow these links to make a purchase, we may get a small commission. This is our only source of support for these forums. Thanks.!