Most "car camping" tents of the Walmart variety, Coleman included, preform very well. In fact, Walmart sells a one and two man knockoff tent that is almost an exact copy of an REI tent, except for the fiberglass hoops. My daughter has one and it's works beautifully for the low price of $42. Problem is weight and size. Most of those tents are in the 6-10 lb. category. You can cut weight by replacing the hoops with aluminum. Still, you'd be in the 6-7 lb. range which is still too heavy. Hammocks will get you down to 1.5-2.5 lbs. For backpacking, I use either a hammock or a 10 oz. tarp setup.