I own a SMD Gatewood cape plus net tent combo, and like that in certain conditions; I've used my tarptent contrail a whole lot more. I think both are good companies.

I'm currently leaning to swapping to a Lightheart designs tent; if a 2-person tent is big enough for you, you might consider the Lightheart Duo. I have to admit that when I was able to "kick the tires" at Trail Days in Damascus VA in May this year, I focused on the solo version, didn't really look at the duo they had set up, but I expect it's a fine choice too.

And it's another cottage company run by passionate hikers, and from what I could tell really nice folks.