So I am looking into a new pack. I have a Kestrel 38 that worked well for the few overnights I have been on but I want to step up to some good through hikes and multi night loops. I have narrowed it down to the two packs listed above. I have a soft spot for Osprey they seem very well made but the price of the REI is really catching my eye. Plus the endorsement from Backpacker doesnt hurt either.

If anyone has tried either or both please comment in if you would please. I don't live anywhere near and REI store so I cannot try out the flash first hand or I would. I have tried on the Exos and the fit is good but the REI is cheaper.