I have a Squall, quality is not an issue. I think it comes down to what you want, lots of space, perfect conditions or to save weight? If you have the money, you want the latest and greatest. I get the impression, that quite a few people who belong to bp forums have good jobs and don't find it an issue to turn over gear and try something else. I think something else that is going on, they are not liking the loss of comfort maybe and are willing to go back up with a slightly heavier item. In looking for a new backpack, the pack weights are going up.