Cook-how did you size yours? I know from the website, there seems to be two ways to do it, depending on how much insulation you want in it. Which way did you go? I just measured my foot using their guide and I actually would wear a woman's size 8 since the smallest man's size is way bigger than my foot. Don't think that matters; they seem to all look alike.

ps. I presume it's cold enough where you are so not being waterproof isn't an issue. Here in CA, a lot of the time, there is snow on the ground, but the temps are so warm people are skiing or snowshoeing in t-shirts. I see they have some kind of waterproofing spray on the website.