I actually think this is a great light for scouts due to the fact that they are so inexpensive. However, as with anything in life, you get what you pay for.

The better headlamps offer much more in terms of durability, consistent light output, better materials, more reliable and better switches, waterproof, better circuitry, etc. I look at the Energizer headlamps and think "disposable" and "toy" rather than a serious headlamp. I don't doubt that it will last beyond a few trips if taken care of, but if I'm relying on it for emergencies, multi-day trips, and more serious light output, then I believe there are better choices.

I don't mean to take away from you liking this headlamp, but it's also good to point out why some would spend a little more on a better quality product...