I am not a fan of multi-tools on the trail for lots of reasons...but wouldn't a simple Swiss Army knife meet most of your requirements? Don't some of them have locking blades? Some of them certainly have scissors...although no manly man is going to carry a tool that as a primary purpose as a pair of scissors!
Registered: 02/05/03
Posts: 3293
Loc: Portland, OR
If a scissors and a locking blade are necessities, then perhaps look at a manicure scissors and an Opinel knife, rather than trying to pull it all together as a multi-tool? I think you could get those two dedicated tools to come in under 4 ounces.
I am not a fan of multi-tools on the trail for lots of reasons...but wouldn't a simple Swiss Army knife meet most of your requirements? Don't some of them have locking blades? Some of them certainly have scissors...although no manly man is going to carry a tool that as a primary purpose as a pair of scissors!
Curious, what is it that you don't like about multi tools? What do you use? (Note, I don't necessarily disagree)
Given that my backpack and tent are made of nylon, I take a sewing kit. And I take a tiny knife for cleaning fish and cutting the salami and cheese we take for lunches.
Screwdrivers/pliers/wrenches etc. serve me for nothing at all...and multi-tools are always heavy. Why carry around stuff that you don't need--or can't use?
I own many multi-tools, but never hike with them. Too heavy, too many tools that serve no purpose on the trail. My primary knife when hiking is a Swiss Army Classic....the tiniest one they make! Has scissors, tweezers, tooth pick, nail file, screw driver, blade, all in about an ounce. If I need a locking blade, which is rare, I'll carry a retasked kitchen boning knife, again very lightweight and strong. Leatherman makes an S4 Squirt with scissors as it's primary tool, but no locking blade. It's a 2 oz. tool. I have the version with pliers as the primary and carry it often, but not hiking.
My primary knife when hiking is a Swiss Army Classic....the tiniest one they make! Has scissors, tweezers, tooth pick, nail file, screw driver, blade, all in about an ounce.
+1 I've never needed more though I suppose if I was in some true survival situation a larger knife would be nicer to have. Hopefully I won't have such bad luck but if I do I'll just improvise.
All makes sense to me-Just curious on the mindset. I was given a very nice multi tool for Christmas and doesn't seem too heavy, but you are right that ounces do add up quickly to pounds.
I'm relatively new to the overnight hiking, but have done plenty of day hiking so I'm always curious as to what people use for gear. All really good info!!
I'm currently carrying a Leatherman Squirt PS4 - knife blade, a couple of screwdriver/nail file tools, pliers, scissors, and small knife; I also carry a small tweezers, since they aren't on the tool. So far, I like the PS4, though I'm still not sure I'll stick with it - something in me always whispering that something designed to do several things doesn't do any of them well. Previously, I carried a Gerber LST Mini lockback pocketknife, folding Fiskars scissors, and tweezers. The PS4 and tweezers weigh the same as the separate knife/scissors/tweezers, but I miss the lockback feature. (I've never had any problems with the non-locking blade.) The extra tools have been somewhat useful: the pliers make a passable pot grabber if the handles get hot or I want to pull the tight-fitting lid off. I've used the screwdriver blades for several things (prying battery covers off headlamps), but not for screwing screws. The scissors are a bit small for serious cutting, but work fine on moleskin and freeze-dried food, or trimming finger or toe nails. Oddly, the knife is what I use least often.
Registered: 02/03/06
Posts: 6800
Loc: Gateway to Columbia Gorge
The Leatherman Squirt PS4 is my go-to knife. It weighs 1.9 oz., has pliers, scissors, etc. There used to be a version that had the scissors as the primary tool, but I didn't look to see if it's still there--look at the Leatherman site to find out. The blade doesn't lock, but I've never used a knife with a locking blade and never have missed it. My first instructions in using a knife (at age 6) stressed that I never rely on the knife to stay open and handle it accordingly. On th other hand, I've never had the blade of mine ever try to close on me when i'm using it.
I use the pliers a lot, primarily as a pot-grabber, but also when threading straps through buckles and other such tasks--I don't have enough fingertip strength to grasp the tiny edge of the strap and pull it through. The pliers are also useful for fishing. For me, those pliers are essential! Other blades I use are the largest screwdriver (to help push webbing straps through tight buckles, or to loosen them for adjustment, or for various prying tasks), the file (for my frequently splitting fingernails), the scissors (for trimming my frequent hangnails and Bandaids as well as for manicure/pedicure), the smallest screwdriver for tightening the screws on my glasses. I even use the knife blade on occasion.
For me, for less than an ounce more than the tiny Swiss knife, the additional functions of the Squirt are well worth it. Buy a knife to suit your individual needs, not for what others tell you. Just don't spend additional money/weight on functions you'll rarely, if ever, use.
_________________________
May your trails be crooked, winding, lonesome, dangerous, leading to the most amazing view--E. Abbey
Registered: 01/04/02
Posts: 1228
Loc: Eastern MA, USA
Darn these tiny tablets and auto corrects! That was supposed to be using not Jesuit. I've had to back up at least 5 times just to post this. Make that 9 times!
I feel your pain. One of these days, my iPad is going to get up close and personal with a wall. (Only three autocorrect corrections to make on this post.)
The Leatherman Raptor is more scissor than all the others and does have a locking blade but it is close to 6 oz. There is one made in India that looks the part but I think the OP has lost interest.
Maybe check out the Leatherman Style CS (not the PS, as it doesn't have a blade and is built around little pliers). It's main tool is the scissors. The blade doesn't lock, but at least it's only about $20 and the handle is a little larger than the Squirt or Micra.
Registered: 01/16/13
Posts: 913
Loc: Nacogdoches, TX, USA
I actually have a Style PS, or at least I did before I gave it to my son. I don't remember why I decided I didn't like it. I also had a Squirt at one point and lost it along with my entire FAK. I miss that one, but I've been eyeing the Micra for the longest time. I've been hiking with the little 1oz SAK, but I can imagine scenarios where that wouldn't be sufficient. Right now, I'm considering the merits of separate tools (Fiskars or Slip n Snip folding scissors, tiny homemade fixed-blade knife, and maybe even a tiny pair of jeweler's pliars). I can never make up my mind. BTW, the homemade knife hasn't been made yet, it's just an idea.
_________________________
The journey is more important than the destination.
Our long-time Sponsor, BackcountryGear.com - The leading source for ultralite/lightweight outdoor gear:
Affiliate Disclaimer: This forum is an affiliate of BackcountryGear.com, Amazon.com, R.E.I. and others. The product links herein are linked to their sites. If you follow these links to make a purchase, we may get a small commission. This is our only source of support for these forums. Thanks.!