It seems to me that Bill does "get it". What he's saying is what it seems most of the people, dog owners and not, on this thread have said - IF your dog does not behave well in the wildnerness setting, it should stay at home; otherwise, fine. I would not bring my best (human) friend on a backpacking trip if they were unable to keep from annoying or harrassing wildlife and other backpackers - same should go for a dog, IMHO.