I have the pack and like it. One complaint I have is the top closure straps. There is one strap going side to side and another going front to back. That would be fine if the top of your load were even but mine frequently are not. Last spring I was out and did not properly cinch the drawcord on the top and the pack contents shifted or something and I ended up loosing my Tarptent. The Tarptent was in a small round stuff sack and was able to fall out through the opening. I am thinking about adding some straps going diagonally across the top. I also miss a top pocket to hold rain jacket, maps, snacks etc. GG offers one as an add on but it is far from being a good solution.