no contest, get the Golite Spike Tail. I have always had a problem finding a shoe, particularly for backpacking, that had a wide enough toebox...especially after a day full of swelling from the miles.

Golite's shoes don't come in half sizes, instead they are labeled as both, i.e. 10/10.5 because they come with several different insoles to choose from to adjust to your foot volume.

Lately, the REI in Seattle has had them on sale. It might be the same at other locations.

good luck!
_________________________
Hike Arkansas! and Hike it All!