I have never used that tent. But I will say that the coleman max brand is better than most cheap tent brands. If you are going to buy a cheap tent, that is probably one of the better ones. It says it has aluminum poles, which is great. If you get it, make sure and set it up in the yard and spray water on it. You might have to seal the seams in the fly and other parts of the tent. The welded floor seam description makes me think that the floor is made from heavy fabric. If it isn't the same fabric as the walls and fly, I would cut the floor out and use a lighter piece of plastic for the floor.

Of course, I make my own tarps. It is really easy to sew a tarp together.