Jim is a bit of a curmudgeon, and as someone who is sometimes accused of being one as well, I think I understand his post. And yes, there are pieces of equipment that I use that some others might think are too heavy or "out of date."

But frankly, I am tired of backpackers who always know what works best. Different equipment works better in some places than others, and in some seasons better than others. Some people don't mind an additional couple of pounds in their packs (my wife always takes two books!) and others like to go as light as possible.

And as long as they get out into the woods and enjoy the experience, the rest of us should probably shut up about it. And all of our advice should carry the warning, YMMV. Your mileage may vary!

Having said that, I do want to point out that the most recent edition of The Compleat Walker includes major sections and recommendations for lots of the new ultralight equipment. And Fletcher is a bit of an old curmudgeon too! (he had help on this section of the book.)