Almost Over the Hill Hikers
  • Over the Hill Hikers [Hardcover]
  • Almost Over the Hill Hikers
    Backpacking Forums
    backcountry gear

    ---- Our Gear Store ----
    The Lightweight Gear Store

    Bivy Bags
    Sleeping Bags
    Sleeping Pads
    Snow Sports
    Winter Kitchen


    Avalanche Gear
    Hats, Gloves, & Gaiters


    Ultralight Backpacks
    Ultralight Bivy Sacks
    Ultralight Shelters
    Ultralight Tarps
    Ultralight Tents
    Ultralight Raingear
    Ultralight Stoves & Cookware
    Ultralight Down Sleeping Bags
    Ultralight Synthetic Sleep Bags
    Ultralight Apparel

    the Titanium Page
    WM Extremelite Sleeping Bags


    Sleeping Bags


    Ropes & Cordage
    Protection & Hardware
    Carabiners & Quickdraws
    Climbing Packs & Bags
    Big Wall
    Rescue & Industrial






    Men's Footwear
    Women's Footwear


    Mens Apparel
    Womens Apparel


    Black Diamond
    Granite Gear
    La Sportiva


    Top Brands
    All Brands

     Backpacking Equipment 

    Sleeping Bags
    Water Treatment

     Backcountry Gear Clearance

    Stay Healthy--Eat Well


    Mary Janes Farm Organic Backcountry Meals


    Natural High


    Topic Options
    Rate This Topic
    #197930 - 03/13/17 12:13 PM bucking the consumer tide- back packs.
    the-gr8t-waldo Offline

    Registered: 01/16/11
    Posts: 134
    Loc: Tacoma, Washington
    There seems to be an unlimited number of internal framed back packs out there. And as I renew my interests in backpacking, after an 30some year hiatus, I find that I'm drawn back towards the external style. Hoping there's more carrying comfort in the older style. about all there is out there is the kelty Tioga.... a brand that frankly, I've associated with low quality. I would like to take an externially braced one out on this years section hike. -just to try, not own at this point. Is there an rental option? And what other brands are there in the 55-65 range?

    #197933 - 03/13/17 02:51 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    Glenn Roberts Offline

    Registered: 12/23/08
    Posts: 1484
    Loc: Southwest Ohio
    If you liked the old external frames, you'll love the new ones: Osprey's Exos and Atmos AG series are both good. Deuter also makes some; I forget what they're called.

    You won't see the Exos or Atmos advertised as external frame (or as internal frame, for that matter), but they are; the perimeter frame and trampoline back are the giveaways. However, these are very high-tech internal frame packs - no more sewer pipes welded together, with the hip belt and boxy pack bag attached by some clevis pins. Now, you get a sleek packbag with all the bells and whistles, attached firmly to the the arrow-shaft high-strength aluminum frame, and a hipbelt that is integrated into the packbag and suspension.

    They really are a breed apart from the old Kelty and Camp Trails pack frames we all used to have. As Carly Simon (Carole King?) used to sing, "THESE are the good old days!" Give them a try.

    As far as rentals, I'm not much help. I think my local shop has these in their rental program; REI might, too. I don't know if any of the college programs have these to rent - they seem to lag the state of the (m)art by a good many years.

    Edited by Glenn Roberts (03/13/17 02:53 PM)

    #197934 - 03/13/17 04:52 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: Glenn Roberts]
    Lonerock Offline

    Registered: 12/10/15
    Posts: 32
    Loc: Southern Oregon
    Up until a couple of years ago I was using a Camp Trails external frame I bought in 1990. I have no major complaints with it other than the weight which is well over 6 lbs.

    Now that I 'm older, I'm looking for a lighter pack and most of those are internal frames. One of the packs I'm considering is the Osprey Exos which is one mentioned by Glenn. REI has a pretty good selection and I know they used to rent gear but not sure if they still do.

    I think though that my preference would be to try some on with weights and see what works for you and buy it if it's not too far beyond your budget (the Exos at REI is $220). That way you'll have something that you like and fits you properly as opposed to a limited selection at a rental place.

    #197943 - 03/14/17 05:57 AM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: Lonerock]
    DTape Offline

    Registered: 11/23/07
    Posts: 660
    Loc: Upstate NY
    One benefit of the older external frame packs which is often overlooked is the ventilation for ones back.

    Externals are not necessarlily heavier either. Many internals are 5+ pounds. My old 1970's era WFS Mont Blanc is less than 3 pounds. I call it "big bird" due to the color.

    #197945 - 03/14/17 12:15 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    the-gr8t-waldo Offline

    Registered: 01/16/11
    Posts: 134
    Loc: Tacoma, Washington
    Thanks all. It appears that I hadden't fully appreciated the current crop of backpacks available. I'm currently in the desert and hard to justify a 200rt mile outing to look at packs, but in a few weeks I'll be able to visit some good supply stores to look at the osprey offerings mentioned. P.S. from my surfing- Seattle ( home base) rents backpacks, but no mention of types or conditions...guess its a case of simply dropping in and talking to one of the staff.

    Edited by the-gr8t-waldo (03/15/17 11:41 AM)

    #197946 - 03/14/17 03:33 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    OregonMouse Offline

    Registered: 02/03/06
    Posts: 6489
    Loc: Gateway to Columbia Gorge
    For me, the internal frame pack revolutionized my backpacking. The external frame inevitably zigged when I zagged, leading to some potentially serious falls. The internal frame pack moves with me, making hiking much safer.

    YMMV, of course!

    I still have my old Kelty external frame pack bought in 1986. I think it's a Tioga, or similar. If you want it, it can be had for the cost of shipping. Otherwise it goes to the local Goodwill.

    Edited by OregonMouse (03/14/17 03:35 PM)
    May your trails be crooked, winding, lonesome, dangerous, leading to the most amazing view--E. Abbey

    #197947 - 03/14/17 05:04 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    JustWalking Offline

    Registered: 01/12/16
    Posts: 167
    Loc: PNW
    Seek Outside makes external frame packs that are exceptionally comfortable and can carry a heavy load when necessary with aplomb. I use one for winter camping and when I know I'll have to carry extra water. (I have no ties to Seek Outside, just a happy camper/customer).

    #197955 - 03/14/17 06:26 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: OregonMouse]
    Glenn Roberts Offline

    Registered: 12/23/08
    Posts: 1484
    Loc: Southwest Ohio
    For me, too, Mouse. I've tried the Exos and Atmos packs; they've reduced the zig-zag effect by half or more, but I can still feel it trying to argue with my directional choices. I always revert back to an internal frame. (Current favorites: Osprey Kestrel 48 or Deuter ACT Zero 50+15, with a very slight edge to the Osprey. This week.)

    #197964 - 03/15/17 12:18 AM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: Glenn Roberts]
    wandering_daisy Offline

    Registered: 01/11/06
    Posts: 2794
    Loc: California
    We all have had different experiences! I still have my old kelty (1968) as well as a newer kelty frame I got for $20 at an REI garage sale. I discarded the pack bag and put on new hip belt, sternum strap and shoulder straps (a lot lighter versions), and sewed my own bag (very light). The Kelty is now about 3.5 pounds, closer to 4 when I add the extension bar. I use the extension bar to latch the bear can on solidly (I actually put the extension bar on backwards for this use). My "home-made" Kelty works very well when I have to carry a lot. It definitely carries 40+ pounds more comfortably than my 2-3 pound internal packs. IT is the unlimited volume that I like. Especially long trip, with bear can, being the Sherpa for my family.

    I grew up with external frames, mountaineering. We did a lot of actual technical stuff with these packs. I guess it is a matter of simply using what you have. I never gave it a thought that I could NOT do technical stuff.

    Other uses for an external frame - lash two together and you have a litter to carry out an injured climber. Stand it up when setting up a tarp above timber (before days of trekking poles).

    When I start with about 40 pounds, I always agonize over using the Kelty or an internal frame (comfortable to 35 pounds). Much of the time I just put up with the pain of the internal frame for about three days until the weight gets down to 35 pounds. So I can be comfortable the first few days or carry a pound more the last days. It is a toss up.

    By the way, these heavy load trips are often 14-day trips without resupply. I rarely carry the Kelty for a trip of 8 days or less.

    #197965 - 03/15/17 12:21 AM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: Glenn Roberts]
    wandering_daisy Offline

    Registered: 01/11/06
    Posts: 2794
    Loc: California
    Forgot to add. With either types of packs, the small details of weight distribution obtained by very precise packing make a lot of difference. More so in an external, as it is less forgiving. When I pack it right, I rarely feel any zig-zag. I have done 3rd class climbing in my Kelty. As well as winter mountaineering (on skiis). And it is all about fit-fit-fit! If the pack does not fit you properly, it will pull you over.

    #197974 - 03/17/17 06:32 AM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    PerryMK Offline

    Registered: 01/18/02
    Posts: 1168
    Loc: Florida panhandle
    I till have an old Camp Trails Adjustable II external frame that weighs in a 3 lbs 14oz. I see these on ebay every so often and even purchased one for parts.

    I also have a new Vargo Ti Arc titanium external frame that weighs just under 3 lbs.

    Building my own external frames to adapt to packs is an off and on hobby of mine. I have progressed through different designs. Below is a photo of a day pack to which I added a homemade external frame. It has only two contact points and no mesh, all ventilation. I have since added a water bottle cage to it that I can access without removing the pack.

    There are a number of manufactures of external frames. The 'traditional' styles that I see online are made by Kelty and Alps. There are a number of manufactures specializing in military and hunting packs that also make external frame packs.


    #200438 - 03/18/18 01:00 PM Re: bucking the consumer tide- back packs. [Re: the-gr8t-waldo]
    pinhotiBill Offline

    Registered: 03/17/18
    Posts: 5
    Loc: Alabama
    I dream of getting a Z-packs Arc Blast or Arc Haul.
    Sort of a modern take on an external frame.
    A bit pricey...but very light weight.


    Shout Box

    Highest Quality Lightweight Down Sleeping Bags
    Western Mountaineering Sleeping Bags
    Lite Gear Talk - Featured Topics
    Trail Running shoes with good support
    by pdslates
    06/14/18 03:48 PM
    by PerryMK
    06/14/18 10:12 AM
    Help neede with clothing
    by SQWIB
    06/07/18 01:41 PM
    Backcountry Discussion - Featured Topics
    Rain gear for tall!!
    by willie1280
    06/11/18 12:57 PM
    What's your water crossing technique/method?
    by willie1280
    06/08/18 08:09 AM
    Apparently I am distinguished...
    by balzaccom
    05/16/18 02:58 PM
    Make Your Own Gear - Featured Topics
    Homemade Potty Trowel
    by 4evrplan
    04/23/16 12:04 AM
    creating fill marks on titanium cookware
    by the-gr8t-waldo
    07/18/15 05:19 PM
    Featured Photos
    Breakneck Ridge, New York
    May 2012 Eclipse, Lassen Park
    New Years Eve 2011
    Trip Report with Photos
    Seven Devils, Idaho
    Oat Hill Mine Trail 2012
    Dark Canyon - Utah
    Who's Online
    0 registered (), 33 Guests and 0 Spiders online.
    Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
    Newest Members
    Yana, Prainz, seabass199, djbdde2, Bill1952
    12586 Registered Users
    Forum Links
    Site Links
    Family Hiking
    Lightweight Gear Store
    Backpacking Book Store
    Lightweight Zone
    Hiking Essentials

    Outdoor Gear Daily Deals
    Outlets, Sales, Bargains

    Our long-time Sponsor, - The leading source for ultralite/lightweight outdoor gear:

    Backcountry Forum

    Since 1996 - the Original Backcountry Forum
    Copyright © The Lightweight Backpacker &