I chose the Scarp 2 (on order) because I want to use it for both winter and summer. For summer, you really need the mesh inner, and for winter, it would be really nice to have the solid inner.
I'm also experimenting with a GoLite Shangri-La 3 with bug netting I'm sewing and Velcroing in instead of using their heavy "nest" option.
At 3 votes for the Scarp v. 3 votes for the Seedhouse, we're acting a lot like lawyers: If we're as smart as we want you to think we are, how come half of us are always wrong?
I would suggest the Scarp. Can be setup fly first and then the tent body second much easier then the other 2. When the heavens really open and it is coming down the inside will stay nice and dry where as the other 2 might be kinda wet! You can set them up so the inside stays dry, but it is not as easy.
I've heard the Scarp 1 has plenty of room, and the dimensions seem to confirm this. I chose the 2-person version because I'll often have another person with me.
The Scarp 1 is in production. I think tents with the 2010 mods have already shipped, but sold out and a new run is being done.
Henry Shires keeps his customers will informed about what's going on. Very impressive!
From now on both the Scarp 1 and 2 will be of the 2010 type. Henry is off to Scotland to do the TGO challenge (using the Moment) Franco franco at tarptent dot com
tarptent's website is stating that as of may 11th the Scarp1 is in production... I assume that means its currently being manufactured...or does it mean its in production ready to go?
Should i wait for the TGO challenge to be over before ordering?
I have some time before my big trip but would like to use the tent some to get comfortable with the setup/packing etc
_________________________
I do it because I can...it also helps that you are not there...
"Should i wait for the TGO challenge to be over before ordering?" Tarptent is shipping out tents as I write this, whilst Henry is having fun. Fiddling with the tent before real use is a great idea. Take your time doing that, each tent has it's own peculiarities so get to know them. Here is my video clip on setting up the Scarp http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWE0gx7rSXU&feature=channel
Sorry, maybe my comment was not very clear. The tents that are in stock at Tarptent (Nevada City) are shipping , that happens with or without Henry being there. The tents listed as "in production" are bing manufactured in Seattle , then shipped to Tarptent. The orders are processed first come , first served. So if you place an order now for a Scarp 1 you get in line to receive your tent when it arrives at Tarptent. BTW, I don't get paid for this, it is just to inform you on what is happening... Franco
WEll my credit card was billed today, and based on the emails from tarptent i should assume that means it has shipped... any idea how long it will take to reach me here on the east coast? I'm working from home the next few days and would love to pitch my Scarp and shoot some emails out from my yard!
_________________________
I do it because I can...it also helps that you are not there...
Registered: 07/31/08
Posts: 94
Loc: Michigan, just N of detroit
I have been in the quarter dome 1 and the SL1 I the SL1 is lighter and has more room, even better get the fly creek 1 (which I own) the problem with the scarp 1 is its not a full two wall tent and would have more condensation than the others due to a lack of mesh in the roof, which is where most of the water condenses and then drips on you, this is not opinion just the way condensation works so I would think about this before you make up your mind.
Fly creek ul1 2lbs 3ozs with space on your sides to spare and great ventilation thats why I choose it.
I have been in the quarter dome 1 and the SL1 I the SL1 is lighter and has more room, even better get the fly creek 1 (which I own) the problem with the scarp 1 is its not a full two wall tent and would have more condensation than the others due to a lack of mesh in the roof, which is where most of the water condenses and then drips on you, this is not opinion just the way condensation works so I would think about this before you make up your mind.
Fly creek ul1 2lbs 3ozs with space on your sides to spare and great ventilation thats why I choose it.
Of course the Scarp 1 is a double walled tent. The inner wall helps manage exactly what you are referring to - condensation. If it does drip, it will drip onto the inner tent wall, not your sleeping bag. It really has it all over the Fly Creek - dual vestibules, dual doors, and superior ventilation. Oh yes, and more width, more length, and much more headroom.
and this is 1 liter of water inside that fabric. I had that up for 12 hours , no drips. Keeping a finger against it and letting go did not make any difference.
Didn't know you could pitch the interior sepreate with the cross poles...pretty crazy demonstration of the water too...lol...lets hope i'm never lyning underneath that tho
_________________________
I do it because I can...it also helps that you are not there...
Interesting demo. I'm a little confused, however. Why would the inner tent be so water resistant? Wouldn't one want maximum porosity in the inner tent?
That fabric does breath very well and the water resistance in a way is a bit deceiving. As a static hold it does keep that much water and probably more (I just put a liter because most can relate to that) and I know that it can take a good shower (I discovered that when I did the freestanding inner bit) however it will not take solid rain. So in effect it works very well as a drip barrier but still breathes . The reason I did that inner freestanding bit was simply because the usual critics came out with that objection (you know the : great tent but...you cannot have the inner up by itself") not that many do that but was just to show it can be done. (I made my own pockets to sit the poles in, the pocket connect to the four corners) In reality if you leave both doors open there is plenty of exposed areas with the fly still on. Franco
Our long-time Sponsor, BackcountryGear.com - The leading source for ultralite/lightweight outdoor gear:
Affiliate Disclaimer: This forum is an affiliate of BackcountryGear.com, Amazon.com, R.E.I. and others. The product links herein are linked to their sites. If you follow these links to make a purchase, we may get a small commission. This is our only source of support for these forums. Thanks.!